16 February 2019
Qian Wang
Senior Economist of Vanguard in Asia
Get Updates from Qian Wang
# #
A Rising Tide of QE in Japan Isn’t Lifting All Boats
Share This Story

The Bank of Japan’s latest quantitative easing program hasn’t been very successful (so far, anyway) in pushing consumer prices higher.

The aggressive bond-buying program, launched in April 2013, was designed to jolt Japan out of more than a decade of deflation and spur economic expansion. Along with fiscal stimulus and structural reforms, quantitative easing—or QE—is one of the “three arrows” in Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s quiver aimed at reviving the Japanese economy.

But after stripping out the latest value-added tax hike.even with Japan’s central bank upping asset purchases in November 2014 to an annual pace of ¥80 trillion (roughly $650 billion at today’s exchange rate) to counter the effects of falling consumption and crude oil prices, inflation is still running at somewhere around 0% to 0.5%. That level is still far off the Bank of Japan’s target of 2%.

Collateral effects from quantitative easing 

Of course, providing that level of monetary stimulus has had other ramifications. The yen has depreciated by about 20% against the dollar since the program was announced. And central bank purchases of Japanese government bonds (JGBs) have pushed down borrowing costs. In fact, the pace of its purchases has contributed to yields on short-term JGBs moving into negative territory at times.

Institutional investors like Japan’s Government Pension Investment Fund have effectively been crowded out of the government bond market because the Bank of Japan is snapping up so much supply. So they’ve had to go elsewhere.

The local stock market has been one beneficiary. The Nikkei 225 Index has risen sharply since the program began, climbing past the 20,000 mark to reach an 18-year high.

And money has flowed out of the country as well in search of higher-yielding opportunities. One destination has been U.S. Treasuries: Japanese investors now have well over $1.2 trillion in these securities, making the Japanese, along with the Chinese, the largest foreign holders. The 2.12%yield of the 10-year U.S. Treasury bond at the end of May might not seem that enticing, but it was well above the 0.39% yield on offer from JGBs of the same maturity.

Potential counterweight to global monetary tightening 

In a low-growth, low-inflation landscape, ultra-loose monetary policy and quantitative easing programs like Japan’s—and the one launched in March by the European Central Bank—may help soften the impact of monetary tightening in the United States when the Federal Reserve eventually begins to raise interest rates. (See the chart below showing the rise in central bank assets relative to 2008 GDP.)

The International Monetary Fund expects Japan’s quantitative easing to help counter the impact of tightening financial conditions globally.The IMF anticipates that portfolio rebalancing by Japanese banks and institutional investors over the medium term could result in additional capital outflows of as much as $260 billion.

When liftoff in the United States does happen, expect to see volatility pick up. Investors who are broadly diversified across bond maturities and bond markets, however, are likely to have a less bumpy ride.

Index of global central bank assets to 2008 GDP 

a rising tide 1 

Qian Wang, Senior Economist of Vanguard Asia.

© 2015 The Vanguard Group, Inc. All rights reserved. Used with permission.

To add comments please Login
Join Our Online Community
Join the Better Way To Retire community and get access to applications, relevant research, groups and blogs. Let us help you Retire Better™
FamilyWealth Social News
Follow Us